Showing posts with label Government. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Government. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 16, 2019

Is Marie Kondo bad for the economy? A Thought Exercise on Global Demand



U.S. consumers spend, and the global economy depends on it. Though the 320 mn U.S. population is only about 4% of the global population, U.S. consumption represents 10.6% of global GDP, and this figure’s impact is understated since the rest of the world’s investments, exports, and consumption associated with U.S. consumption is excluded. So, if ‘Tidying Up with Marie Kondo,’ the new Netflix show that helps people combat hoarding embrace minimalism, becomes the new norm, does it mean the economy will suffer?

I believe the answer is no, but it requires advanced economies to sort out housing and emerging markets to figure out politics. With 7 bn in global population, there is no shortage of people who want to live the good life. Regardless of the different views on materialism and frugality and the different stages on Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, people want modern shelter, appliances, technology, and conveniences. However, the first problem is that increasingly those who have the means don’t need or want to spend. The second problem is that those who truly need don’t have the means to spend.

Let’s take Japan, the third largest economy in the world, for example. Japan’s elderly owns most of the wealth, but the lack of desires, retirement insecurities, or concerns for their kids’ future keep them from living it up. The problem underneath is Japan’s bad demographics. The country’s bad demographics, characterized by the rapidly aging population and low fertility rates, threaten the stability of the stability of the retirement system and the vibrancy of the economy and its future prospects.

As for what explains the bad demographics, I believe housing played a big role. Japan’s massive housing bubble made having children expensive, unreachable, and undesirable. Buying a home or paying rent is an option for a young individual, but having a stable home becomes more of a necessity for a couple looking to raise a family. As a result, when Japan’s housing price outpaced wage gains, it became rational for people to have fewer kids or forgo having kids.


Increasingly, this trend may play out in U.S. as well. The combination of the knowledge economy’s cluster effect and global wealth investing in U.S. cities have driven up housing prices in metropolitan cities. For instance, the tech jobs in San Francisco, the finance jobs in New York, and the biotech jobs in Boston draw young talents to these cities. This results in a cluster effect where the talent influx creates a bigger ecosystem for these jobs, which draws even more people to these cities. In addition to the increase in demand from the population growth, investors also add to those who wish to own a piece of these growing cities.


In the end, the high home prices reduce these residents’ disposable income in the short-run and may reduce their willingness to have children in the long-run. While wage gains and home prices ebb and flow, these advanced economies’ demand becomes permanently impacted once demographic takes a dip. As a result, housing plays a big role on why advanced economies may decide to spend less than they are able to.














As for the second problem, emerging markets’ messy politics often prevent them from achieving their full potential. China is a poster boy on how politics matter. Since Deng opened up China with a single-minded focus on pursuing growth, China has been on a tear. In the past decades, China has lifted close to 800 mn of its 1.3 bn population out of poverty. Growth inducing policies allowed people to get jobs and buy things to improve their quality of life. However, things may be starting to slow in China.

Automobile sales contracted for the first time in 20 years and smartphone sales have been falling for over a year now. This doesn’t mean that China is running into a wall or a crisis, but it does mean that it is important for other emerging market to take over the baton for demand. The difficulty is that there are few countries can match China’s size and trajectory for growth. Messy politics have kept other large emerging markets such as Brazil, India, and Indonesia from achieving their full growth potential. Politics matter because bad policies prevent technology and organizations from maximize productivity and full utilizations of their land, labor, and capital.

China Automobile Sales (mn of units)  

China Smartphone Shipments (mn of units)

As I see it, there are five ways to tackle the two problems so that Marie Kondo doesn’t become the new scape goat for a global economic slowdown.
  1. Transfer money from the haves to the haves-nots in the advanced economies and emerging markets for them to spend.
  2. Lend money to the haves-nots in the advanced economies and the emerging markets for them to spend.
  3. Encourage investments in financial securities and discourage investments in real estate.
  4. Loosen building and zoning laws and adopt accelerated building techniques to meet housing demand.
  5. Influence emerging markets to pursue better growth policies and achieve more global economic coordination for mutual gains.

However, not all of these solutions are feasible, practical, or advised. First, transferring money is not productive and will be lobbied hard against. Second, lending money to those who can’t payback results in high non-performing loans at best and another economic crisis at worst. Third, channeling wealth from real estate is possible, but the current homeowners will become unhappy voters. Fourth, turning every desirable metropolitan city into dense concrete jungles of stacked modular apartments works on paper, but not in practice. This leaves the last option, which is also the best out of all the potential solutions.

The difficulty here lies in the world’s current state of political economy. As politicians around the world see global economy as a zero-sum game (maybe globalization or the winner-takes-all development has indeed turned it into a zero-sum game), this also makes the last option unlikely. 

So, what will happen and will Marie Kondo become the scapegoat? I don’t think so, but may be it is not impossible. 

Thursday, June 22, 2017

Casino Like Financial Markets



In this world where too much money is chasing too few assets, asset price inflation and subsequently, gambling on prices, become inevitable. This means that financial markets may turn into casinos, but this outcome is better than the alternatives.

To begin, money and assets are different in that money is cash, deposits, and cash like funds while assets are things that provide future benefits. In the past 70 years, the combination of post WWII peace, globalization, and the break from gold standard has led to the creation of lots of money. Peace allows households to just live and enjoy life, giving them the opportunity to make money without interruption. Globalization enables those who are good at making money to make lots of it. Lobster men in Maine and miners in Mongolia can now sell their goods far and wide at speeds and scales unseen before. Fiat currency made money printing possible. Whether the printing is to meet genuine economic demand or spurred by government stimulus, central banks no longer had to worry whether they have enough gold to back their money up. Putting it all together, it has been a perfect storm for money creation.

As for assets, there is simply not enough of it. There are lots of consumption goods, but there are not enough investment goods. While they both provide future benefits, only investment goods are assets worth chasing with one’s money. Since consumption goods’ values expire and depreciate, it makes little sense for people to park their money in these assets that lose value. As a result, money naturally gravitates toward investment goods, lured by the promise of capital preservation and appreciation. (Preservation is important because inflation eats away the value of money and appreciation is desired because what is a better way to make money than to make money with money).

What does this mean altogether? It means that asset prices will rise over time since there is too much money chasing too few assets.  Money has to go somewhere and it will pour into available assets. However, the process is messy and unpredictable (largely). The inflow of money is disorderly, unlike water filling an ice cube tray. Money will come in and out and assets will rise and fall. This volatility makes it difficult for assets to find and stay at an equilibrium price. Such opportunity to make quick bucks by predicting the direction of prices draw people in and those who captured by their animal spirits turn into gamblers. Also, as markets become more sophisticated, the typical buy low sell high strategy has evolved beyond one’s imagination. Instead of picking good stocks or a good house, there are now strategies betting on prices, interest rates, exchange rates, spreads, volatilities, and everything else.   

However, this is not a bad thing. This casino is better than other forms of gambling. Financial markets create much more good than Las Vegas’s casinos or horse race betting. Furthermore, it is much better to isolate the gambling on investment goods than consumption goods.

First, unlike Las Vegas and race tracks that end up creating lavish hotels and genetically engineered horses, this casino allocates capital, creates endless jobs, and spreads financial literacy. Though gambling sounds bad, the large number of market participants help enable a deep market. This deep market increases the possibility of someone out there willing to take the other side of the trade as a buyer or a seller. Whether it is buying a stock, foreign exchange, or an interest rate swap, one can feel confident that their transaction will go through at a given price. Through this deep market, resources can be allocated more efficiently. Stock picking rewards good companies by giving them a cheaper cost of capital. Foreign exchange forwards allow companies to put their idle foreign exchange to good use to those who wants to buy it now for the future. Interest rate swaps enable companies to swap their less desired fixed interest rates for a preferred floating exchange rate. Also, ever since financial markets evolved from a room of loud traders to electronic markets that now exists in the clouds, financial markets can now create jobs anywhere. In comparison, the jobs created by casino and race tracks are mostly limited to those within the proximity of these sites. Lastly, working as part of the value chain of financial markets, one is able to become an expert in financial matters. These workers are not only able to use these skills for themselves, but also become agents to spread financial literacy to others. Financial skill is much more applicable and useful compared to knowing how to deal in black jack and knowing how to brush horse’s hair.  

Second, it is much better to have this casino on investment goods than consumption goods. If the flood of money is channeled toward chasing consumption goods, it would no longer be known as capital appreciation, but as hyperinflation. The first allows people to preserve and grow their wealth while the second destroys their wealth through the erosion in their purchasing power. One is happy to see his or her 401K investment balance goes up, but one will be distraught to see the price of daily items spin out of control. One observable example can now be seen through housing. Homes are both a consumption good and investment good. People consume housing for shelter, but they also invest in homes for their retirement. The dual purpose real estate serves doubles the demand for this asset. As a result, home prices have skyrocketed in past decades as more and more wealth chases this asset, which often struggles to keep up with the demand. This phenomenon has forced poorer people out of their neighborhoods at best and created destructive housing bubbles at worst. Even till today, housing continues to be a thorny issue despite the numerous painful experiences of housing bubble bursts in Japan, US, Europe, and elsewhere.


In the end, we are left to choose our own poison. By accepting conflict, protectionism, and gold standards, one can create a world with less money. However, the weak and powerless will undoubtedly suffer more. Destruction is more costly to them, protectionism hurts poor nations’ income and deprives rich nations from cheap goods, and gold standards limit stimulus and cheap credits. If one accepts the current arrangement and let money creation continue, then one may be left with hyperinflation or casino like financial markets. I do not know about you, but between the two, I pick casino like financial markets. 

Thursday, August 25, 2016

Why Everyone Should be a Fed Watcher


Heading into Jackson Hole, many financial market participants are eagerly watching Fed Chairwoman Yellen’s every move. As if they are not already, they will be glued to their smartphones and tablets, watching out for any pop up news of Yellen’s speech. They want to know if September is a go.



Image result for federal reserveThis go means Fed hikes rates. To profit and loss minded investors, this will be huge news. The rate hike will determine whether the dollar will resume its appreciation, the equity and bond market will deflate, and international markets will slow down. To casual followers of capital markets and the economy, this means that the government believes in the strength of the US economy and maybe their mortgage rates will go up. However, to most people, this means nothing. Whether young or old, they will look up at their TV, stare across at their computers, or swipe away on their smartphones, thinking “I don’t care and this is boring.”
I do not blame them, but I believe everyone should be paying attention to the Fed and this is to their own benefit. The anticipated 25 basis point interest rate hike, when and if it comes, has a butterfly effect on everyone and those who predict it well has the best chance of survival and prosperity. You may think I am exaggerating, but hear me out.
Just like farmers rely on the weather, modern workers rely on the economy. A farmer can be diligent and resourceful with seeds, but if the weather and conditions are bad, the farmer’s crops will go nowhere. Similarly, a modern worker can be hard working and endowed with money or education, but if the economy trajectory and economy are bad, the workers will have very limited success. A new home buyer couple, a college graduate and a middle management dad during the 2008 financial crisis all suffered. The couple ended up overpaying for a house and are stuck paying mortgage for the next 30 years. The student who did everything right, but still fell short of finding a job after school. The dad, who helped the company throughout the year, got laid off because the corporate said so.
As a result, it is easy to see that the weather and economy have a great impact on the farmer and worker. The difference is that good farmers try their best to predict the weather and adapt to different conditions while good workers generally have little understanding of the economy and allow the economy to batter them around without any adjustment or a clue. At this point, one may have two burning questions: what can workers do and how can they predict the economy?
For the first question, it is no different from the farmer. Just like the farmer who foresaw the poor rains this season and decided to plant a less water intensive crop, one should evaluate conditions before making a big purchase or investment. Whether it is buying a house or going to school, people should make sure their plans (crop) fit the economy (weather). If their plans do not fit, then they should be open, if not eager, to change. The ever growing students at coding schools are a perfect example of this change. Perhaps interested by tech or discouraged by their current field, people adapt to learn skills that seemingly will fit the economy. There is no way for sure to know whether this will work out, but it beats the odds of the stubborn farmer who refuses to leave his barren land.
As for the second question, I say watch the Fed. The Fed is not only stacked with brilliant economists and researchers, but also it is tasked with changing the economy (weather). To understand what I mean here, imagine how farmers observe and predict the weather. The Fed is more than just a wise and experienced farmer who watches the clouds, feel the wind, and observe seasonal patterns to predict the weather. The Fed is an Elon Musk like disrupter who will play god to change the weather and economy. The Elon Musk reference is to his proposal to nuke Mars to induce create a sun and warm up the planet for future inhabitants. Well, unless one thinks Fed’s QE is on the level of Elon Musk’s idea, one should just think of the Fed as a modern day engineer who cloud seeds for rain and build dams and levers to control water. (I will stop here because this is not a blog on Fed’s monetary policy channels, communication, and impact) Therefore, by following the Fed, one should be able to understand the current and future trajectory of the economy. Before people were treated as robots and shuffled inside giant factories or office buildings, they paid attention to and adapted to weather. Today, people should take back this skill and pay attention to and adapt to the economy.

Just like sailors do not set sail without checking for storms, people should not live their lives without paying attention to the economy. The captain and crew can pray to their gods all they want and wish for smooth sailing, but the storm will find them if they do not check and prepare for the weather. People can find “the economy” boring all they want, but the economy will find them if they act like it has no relevance to their lives. Fast forward a few 100 years, it is now easy to find any weather information that is timely and accurate. However, information and accurate views on the economy is more difficult. Given there is no app that will tell you everything you need to know about this week’s weather with just a quick swipe, just do your homework and study the Fed.
http://filmint.nu/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/interstellar-farm-550x230.jpeg
So is Murph’s brother Tom a good farmer? He is on a doomed planet, but he does switch around his crops…

Sunday, July 24, 2016

Moon, Stars, Wage Growth Next?

We all know the cliched saying, "always aim for the moon, even if you miss, you will land amongst the stars." This saying usually applies to parents who are trying to motivate their children, but it is increasingly taking shape in the economic and finance world. I got the idea reading the diplomat's coverage of the World Bank President, Dr. Kim. Dr. Kim aimed for the moon with his "3-by-5 pledge." He states that he aims to treat 3 mn people in developing countries with an anti- HIV/AIDS drug by 2005 during his tenure at the UN. The pledge ended up being unfulfilled, but the 3 mn target is reached in 2007, earlier than previous expected. Kim says his policies worked because "you have to set a really difficult target and then have that really difficult target change the way you do your work.” He has employed the same philosophy at the World Bank, but tackling poverty's causes and effects simultaneously is a very difficult challenge. Needless to say, he has yet to "land amongst the stars" at the World Bank.


This idea has also played out in industrial policies. South Korea's Park Chung Hee implemented policies that led to Korea's future industrial dominance. South Korea is now market leaders in steel, shipbuilding, autos, chemicals, and electronics. By striving to reach difficult output or export targets, chaebols were pressured to make significant breakthroughs in short amounts of time. This achievement did not come easily since the foreigners, importers, consumers, and laborers' interests were sacrificed in the process, but they did it. Though they often missed out on short term targets, the difficult goal helped them move with more urgency in improving their operations, technology, and management. This all sounds well and good, but China under Mao was a different story. Ambitious targets to beat US and UK in steel output during the Great Leap Forward led to disastrous outcomes. Drunk with hopes of a new China, wishes for a egalitarian society, and spells of Mao's cult of personality, people dived into this project with fervor. Seemingly overnight, useful bicycles, cookware, and machinery were dumped into giant furnaces and turned into giant heaps of metal crap. Great Leap Forward's bold goals were equivalent to aiming for mars, but China did not land among the moon or the stars, it landed into an era of shortage, starvation, and social upheaval.

Increasingly, this idea has expanded to foreign currency and inflation. Taiwan, the lagger in the four Asian tigers, has failed to meaningfully upgrade its manufacturing industries. Sure TSMC is a big name, but Taiwan has performed below its potential and created fewer competitive firms than expected. One criticism is that the central banks' cheap currency policy has shielded exporters from competition and deprived them of the urgency to upgrade. Recently the central bank has even released a 33 page report responding to a magazine critical on the central bank and its foreign exchange policy. In Japan, academics like Paul Krugman are calling for a 4% inflation target in Japan; the higher inflation rate is expected to help reflation policies since a failure to hit the target will still result in inflation higher than that of today's 0.7%. This policy also gives the government cover for much bigger forms of monetary policies. These talks seem tantalizing, but foreign currency and inflation targets are complicated and policy makers will always err on the side of caution. Considering it is difficult enough to maintain the status quo rather than improve the current situation, do not expect much aiming for the moon.


One part where the cliched saying may evolve next to is in wage hikes. Seeds planted from the 2008 financial crisis has grown to many social movements. From the on start of the Occupy Wall Street movement to Bernie Sanders and Donald Trumps' rise, economic inequality has played a big role. At the moment, given US's high debt and overall political leaning, wage hikes rather than welfare is a more realistic situation. In a country built by self-sufficient and dreamer immigrants, working to help one escape poverty is an acceptable narrative. As the likes of Wal-Mart laud the positive business effects in paying their employees' above market wage and Dimon announces wage hikes at JP Morgan, more meaningful wage hikes has gradually turned into expectation. Furthermore, as cities around the country, from LA to SF to NYC aim to raise wages to $15 an hour, this movement just keeps on growing.


Despite this trend, there is no lack of opposition. Citing price and quantity crosses featured in economic 101 courses , economists believe that wage hikes will decrease overall employment. This economic law is sensible and logical, but the price and quantity cross is not everything. The supply and demand curves are dynamic and next to impossible to capture in frameworks that assumes "ceteris paribus," or everything else the same. However, the louder the critics sound off alarms on wage hikes' negative effect on employment, the less likely cities and corps will stand idly watching their jobs flow out or payroll bloats up. In anticipation of wages hikes' effect on lower employment, cities and companies may compensate for this by adjusting policies to create more opportunities or productivity. Local governments may remove previous red tabs; companies may use new methods to increase productivity. Overall, despite the set backs, perhaps the wage hikes will be a disruptive force that leads to positive shifts in the supply and demand curves rather than a mere change in the price and quantity cross points. I do not have a good way to validate this narrative one way or another, but I do wonder if wage policy will become the next hot bed for the "aim for the moon and land amongst stars" philosophy.


Saturday, March 28, 2015

Balloon Economies (Part 1)


What do you see here? Three work in progress paper mache projects? I see that too, but I also see something more. I see the balloon pasted paper mache as a metaphors that explain economic booms and busts and economic policies.

While I do not know why the artist (who uploaded this picture) wanted big paper mache domes, I do know why politicians want big economies. Big economies empower countries, bolster support, and provide better livelihoods. Especially on the last point, whether motivated by love, duty, power, or pride, politicians strive to improve their countrymen’s economic well-being. Some may say that the pie is big enough and society needs more re-distributive policies to address inequalities. However, given the high political cost and the economic inefficiencies, I believe politicians still see making the economic pie bigger as the simpler policy choice.

As a result, no different from the artist who used the balloon to prop up the paper mache dome, politicians also look for ways to build the economy as big and as quickly as possible. In the picture’s case, the third largest balloon allows the economy to have the biggest GDP and its people the highest GDP per capita. In this scenario, people’s material wealth increases, the government fulfills its promises, and everyone is happy. Here, politicians and entrepreneurs are lionized as geniuses and saviors.

However, the paper mache dome and the economy dome comparison now ends here. While the artist has complete control over when to lift the solidified dome off the balloon or even burst the balloon intentionally to remove the dome, the government does not. The government did not know whether the San Francisco economy is able to wean itself off the dependence on the Tech bubble. The government did not know whether the US economy could hold up if the housing bubble burst. In the end, the ordinary folks who the government sought to help in the beginning are hurt the most. Seemingly overnight, 401Ks are reduced, home equity are halved, and entire departments are laid off. The US economy went through this bubble bursting in 2008. Seven years later, the economy is now finally starting to pick up.

Tuesday, January 6, 2015

Borders to Conflicts and Inequality

One way or another, they sit huddled together quietly, usually with some sort of blanket draped over their backs. They are fatigued, but alert. Wherever they are, whether on a boat or a truck, they are all trying to immigrate to a new land. From the Indonesians going to Australia, the Libyans going to Italy, the Mexicans going to the US, or the Rohingyas going to wherever that accepts them, these migrants leave everyone and risk everything for a chance to get out and get in. Most have grown insensitive to these news, barely raising their eyebrows as they come across these headlines. At the same time, there are also many who share statuses, wear T-shirts, attend rallies, host meeting, and everything else they can do to bring light to the issue. Lastly, there the policy makers who talk about it and… just talk about.

Immigration policy is a hot topic. It stirs up xenophobia. The fear of the undesirable economic, community, and identity impact is enough to turn an otherwise kind individual nasty. Simply put, there is no shortage of why dislike newcomers. However, I believe the popular opinion against immigration actually fails to understand the whole issue. A closed door immigration policy leads to conflicts and economic inequality.

First, the closed door policy strengthen dictatorships and their regimes. For instance, before fences, the immigration centers, and the passports, people were able to migrate more freely. As self-interested humans as they are now and forever will be, they go to places that gives them the best opportunity. Under this system, people flee oppressive regimes more freely for fairer rules. This mobility punishes the bad kings and rewards the good kings since the size of the population determines the kingdom’s military and economic strength. A large population allows a large military, a large tax base, and a large pool of productive workers. As a result, there is a natural accountability system in place to promote progress. However, this current system breaks the natural order. For instance, because developed countries set strict limits on immigration, the policy is not able to accommodate all those who wish to come to enter. Therefore, they are forced to stay and empower the bad kings’ military and economic strength. This translates to a false legitimacy for the bad king, lending him credit and enabling him to conduct the further oppressive policies. So what does this mean for those in the developed countries and how does this hurt them? The closed policy fosters these bad kings, allowing the so called Axis of evil countries to continue their ways. In the end, at least in the case of the US, this leads to military conflict, death, hatred, and terrorism. The xenophobia and closed door policy contributes to the death of young soldiers, terrorist attack victims, and countless tragedies. One may have been able to minimize change by rejecting immigrants, but one has also contributed to a more violent, unstable, unsafe, and tragic world for everyone.


Second, the closed door policy contributes to greater inequality. It is true that the family and environment one is born in plays a great role in determining one’s economic well-being. However, except for the extremely impoverished and wealthy tails of the normally distributed population, most probably lie somewhere in the middle, only differing by the type of house they live in and the type of vacation they go on. As a result, for this group of general population to become richer, they need to work to accumulate their wealth. Yet, it is always easier said than done. High paying jobs are competitive and wage growth is slow. There are many theories behind wage growth, such as the labor productivity gains, the technological improvements, and a country’s monetary policy, but I would just like to focus on one, the supply and demand of the labor. I believe now that developed economies have most of their basic needs met, such as food, housing, clothing, and transportation, the equilibrium supply and demand price has little room to grow. The peak in demand leaves little room for wage pressure; the political pressure to keep employment high leaves little space for supply cuts. These forces combine to cap a lid on wage growth. It is true that new demand can be created, but niche demands only has enough room to benefit a selected few and structural demands take time to form. Therefore, the only logical answer to this wage growth cap is markets with new demands. When one looks around, one will realize there are many such markets. These emerging markets have insatiable demand for modern goods and services, which can translate to high equilibrium supply and demand prices. While it is debatable whether these emerging markets can afford all the modern good and services they need or want, the demand is irrefutable. As a result, anyone who can supply this demand will make a fortune right?

Wrong. Only a selected few will be able to supply this demand. Since those with a deep enough pocket to negotiate with foreign governments and those with a long enough investment horizon to wait for emerging market consumers to pay are able to supply the demand, common folks will lose out again. They may observe the demand, but will not be able to supply the demand and drive up their supply and demand equilibrium wage. As a result, large corporations will again be able to keep a wage ceiling on such jobs due to the large labor supply. They will again either work for in a low wage growth job or fight to death for the competitive, high paying job. In the end, those fortunate enough to be born in the extremely wealth tail of the population will win out again. However, it does not have to be like this. In a more freer border environment, the entry barrier to these emerging markets may be lower and an eager entrepreneur may have a fighting chance against the big corporation. Furthermore, a freer border environment may have a strengthened accountability system mentioned before and the emerging market and developed country gap may be smaller.


Obviously, there are many other things to consider when it comes to immigration. A country’s fiscal budget has to be conserved, a community’s tolerance for foreigners is limited, and most of all, politicians’ political lives are fragile. In the end, whether developed countries’ closed door immigration policies to those in need lead to military conflicts and domestic inequality, politicians will just continue to talk about and… just talk about it.